The incident happened in the Janta Express en route from Delhi to Saharanpur.

The man named Munawwar, who was returning from a Delhi hospital to his home in Shamli district of UP, has been admitted to Delhi’s GTB hospital. Relatives of the victim told the paper that they were informed about the incident by an army personnel who was travelling in the same coach as Munawwar. “The caller told us that there was an altercation over seat sharing,” Mohammad Lukman, the victim’s brother-in-law told the paper.

Over-crowded passenger trains in states like Uttar Pradesh and Haryana frequently witness incidents of violence over seat disputes. 

Most recently on July 2, a woman passenger, Monica Shekhar, travelling from Siwan in Bihar to Delhi was assaulted by a group while the train was between Gorakhpur and Gonda. She said in her complaint that some passengers forcibly tried to take over her seat and, when resisted, beat her and her husband up. 

At times, the violence turns fatal. At least four men have lost their lives on these routes in six months alone. All disputes occurred over seats. 

Here’s a list:

• On June 22, 2017, a youth named Junaid Khan was stabbed to death and his two brothers injured when a group of people attacked them inside a crowded train following dispute over a seat. Reports said the mob also passed communal slurs at them. The incident took place at the Ballabgarh railway station in Haryana.
• On June 5, 2017, a youth named Sandeep was lynched to death at UP’s Chamrola station when he refused to give his seat. The incident took place in the general coach of Anand Vihar-Kanpur Express. Sandeep, son of an Army man, was travelling to Mainpuri from New Delhi, reports The Times of India.

• In March 2017, a 54-year-old man named Kailash Mittal was beaten to death at Bhiwani railway station in Haryana. The dispute happened after a group of 3-4 people entered the train and demanded that Mittal gives up his seat. When he refused, the group attacked him.
• In November 2016, a 29-year-old youth named Ashwini Kumar Sharma was shot dead after The incident happened in a train travelling between Delhi and Saharanpur via Shamli. As per a report by Hindustan, the dispute happened over seat after which Ashwini was shot by a group and he died on the spot.
• In March 2016, a man lost his life in a dispute over seats that occurred in a train between Saharanpur and Meerut Cantt. Five others were injured.

The problem, sadly, has persisted for years but recently came into the limelight after the killing of Junaid Khan. The administration then asked security personnel to keep a tab on men travelling in groups and carrying illegal weapons like­ knives or blunt objects­ in trains.

But security isn’t the only issue the railways need to tackle. Over-crowded trains with passengers travelling for long hours are equally to blame. 

A report in The Times of India points out how scuffles and quarrels are routine in “these humid metallic boxes packed sometimes ten times of their seating capacity”. Commenting on the frequent violence over seats, a commuter Rishi Kumar told TOI, “If you transport people like animals, won’t they behave like them.”