On Monday, the Lok Sabha passed the Right to Information (Amendment) Bill in the face of massive opposition. It was passed with 218 members voting in its favour and 79 against it after a reply by Minister of state for personnel, public grievances and pensions, Jitendra Singh.

According to the original 2005 Act, any Indian can seek information from any authority on the payment of Rs 10. However, the effectiveness of the act hinges on the independence of the Chief Information Commissioner (CIC) and its equivalents in the states. Here’s how the new amendment affects it.

1. The amended bill has done away with the fixed tenure of five years for the Chief Information Commissioner (CIC) and the Information Commissioners (IC). They will now serve for a tenure determined by Centre.

The Centre will also have the power to decide the salary and the perks that the CIC and the ICs receive.


2. The power of appointment for the Chief Information Commissioners (SCIC) and State Information Commissioners (SIC) will lie solely with the Centre.

Currently, the SCICs and SICs are chosen by a three member panel comprising the state CM, the state’s leader of opposition or leader of the largest opposition party in the state assembly and a state cabinet minister nominated the chief minister. The amendment would nullify the independence of the state legislatures. 

Even the CIC and the ICs would serve at the pleasure of the government, which could lead to them being more interested in ensuring the longevity of their tenures rather than serving the citizens’ interests. 


3. Since the Centre would decide the tenure, it follows that they would also be responsible for dismissals. 

In the original bill, the CIC and IC could only be removed by the President – and the state Governor in case of SCIC and SIC – after an enquiry by the Supreme Court finds reason for their dismissal from office. However, if the Centre would be in charge of tenure, they would also be responsible for removals.


The NDA, along with its friendly parties, has the numbers to push the bill through after its passed the Lok Sabha. However, such a contentious bill that puts so much power at the hands of the centre has obviously been met with massive opposition.

Sonia Gandhi said,

The Centre is hell bent on subverting the RTI act.

Other opposition parties have also termed it the ‘RTI Elimination Bill’.

Several others also voiced their dissent.

Further updates are now awaited.